Clue Game 42

Peacock huh. OD suggested Peacock right before his accusation of Mr. Green. I assumed he had good reason not so suggest her, like he had the Peacock card. Shows you what I know. Kind of embarrassing to get only two out of four right. It looked like my three remaining opponents had positioned themselves for double accusation turns so I felt I had to roll the dice. Oh well.

I had: Candlestick, Lead Pipe, Ballroom, Conservatory

Congratulations Miplet. Thanks for all the programming for the day of the week. A welcome change.

Quote: Wizard

Peacock huh. OD suggested Peacock right before his accusation of Mr. Green. I assumed he had good reason not so suggest her, like he had the Peacock card. Shows you what I know. Kind of embarrassing to get only two out of four right. It looked like my three remaining opponents had positioned themselves for double accusation turns so I felt I had to roll the dice. Oh well.

I had: Candlestick, Lead Pipe, Ballroom, Conservatory

Congratulations Miplet. Thanks for all the programming for the day of the week. A welcome change.

I used the same, obviously erroneous reasoning to Elim Peacock. Room was a (wrong) guess.

Congrats, miplet!

Quote: beachbumbabs

Quote: Wizard

Peacock huh. OD suggested Peacock right before his accusation of Mr. Green. I assumed he had good reason not so suggest her, like he had the Peacock card. Shows you what I know. Kind of embarrassing to get only two out of four right. It looked like my three remaining opponents had positioned themselves for double accusation turns so I felt I had to roll the dice. Oh well.

I had: Candlestick, Lead Pipe, Ballroom, Conservatory

Congratulations Miplet. Thanks for all the programming for the day of the week. A welcome change.

I used the same, obviously erroneous reasoning to Elim Peacock. Room was a (wrong) guess.

Congrats, miplet!

Ah! good. Two readings of my reasoning, both flawed. Now if only miplet would get led astray so easily.

Quote: OnceDear

Ah! good. Two readings of my reasoning, both flawed. Now if only miplet would get led astray so easily.

Quote:

Scarlet (OD)
Enters Conservatory
Suggests Mrs. Peacock with Wrench in Conservatory on Saturday
Mustard (mip) can't disprove
White (odg) can't disprove
Green (Dum) can't disprove
Peacock (Wiz) disproves
January 31st, 2018 at 4:54:31 PM

Accuses Mr. Green with Wrench in Dining Room on Thursday
Wrong!
January 31st, 2018 at 4:57:43 PM

If you care to explain why you suggested Peacock and accused Green, I'm all ears. I'm thinking you were 50/50 between Green and Peacock and the answer to the suggestion didn't narrow it down. Perhaps you switched just to mess with the players behind you. If so, well done, you got me.

Quote: Wizard

If you care to explain why you suggested Peacock and accused Green, I'm all ears. I'm thinking you were 50/50 between Green and Peacock and the answer to the suggestion didn't narrow it down. Perhaps you switched just to mess with the players behind you. If so, well done, you got me.

Ok, my logic was not all good*, but here goes:-
I had weapon and day. I'd narrowed suspect to Green or Peacock. I also knew that either miplet held Dining room, or that that was the crime scene and that Peacock held either Peacock or Conservatory and no-one else could hold conservatory, so that might have been crime scene.
I thought it very unlikely that miplet held dining room, so that was my favourite for crime scene, but conservatory was close second favourite. Clearly we all knew weapon and day and many of us probably had similar indicators for room and good shots at suspect, So I had the urge to accuse early.
Knowing Wizard held either Peacock or Conservatory I was torn between heading towards Dining Room or to suggest. But conservatory was so close! In suggesting Peacock, Conservatory, I hoped that Peacock would be shown, in which case I would have been certain that killer was Green and room was still fairly likely to be dining room. That set accusation of Green, Dining room firmly in my head. Being shown Conservatory, I just accused Green because that was what I had programmed myself to do. LOL.
* It was flawed analysis as Peacock was more likely because I knew Green and Plum did not hold Peacock
I stuffed up. Getting the room wrong was incidental.
$:o)

Miplet, could we get a readout of the cards please?

Quote: OnceDear

Ok, my logic was not all good*, but here goes:-...

Thanks for the answer. I have no cross talk but did want to say "thank you."

Quote: OnceDear

Miplet, could we get a readout of the cards please?

Apologies if this has been said before but let the record show Miplet had two of the four cards (wrench and Thursday) in his infamous round 3 turn.

Quote: miplet

Mustard (mip)
Enters Dining Room
Suggests Mrs. White with Wrench in Dining Room on Thursday
White (odg) can't disprove
Green (Dum) can't disprove
Peacock (Wiz) can't disprove
Plum (bbb) can't disprove
Scarlet (OD) can't disprove
January 30th, 2018 at 10:03:42 PM

Quote: Wizard

Apologies if this has been said before but let the record show Miplet had two of the four cards (wrench and Thursday) in his infamous round 3 turn.

And the sneaky devil was holding the other two!
$:o)